No Bullshit Polls – 1 Oct 2004

Bush’s Real Opponent

By David S. Broder

Saturday, October 2, 2004; Page A21

President Bush and Sen. John Kerry faced very different challenges when they met Thursday night for their first debate, but only Kerry seemed to recognize exactly what he needed to do.

The Democratic nominee’s task was to straighten out the internal contradictions that had facilitated the successful Republican assault on him as a flip-flopper. He bent every effort to the urgent need to appear straightforward and strong — keeping his back straight, his head high, his answers short and his thoughts clear. For most of the night, he was the aggressor, pressing the case for a change of command in the war on terrorism, which has been Bush’s strongest suit.

Bush had a different assignment. A Kerry weakened by months of Republican rhetoric painting him as a vacillating wimp was far less of a threat to a second term than the disturbing news bulletins and television pictures from the Iraq battlefront. Bush’s need was to reconcile his upbeat rhetoric about the coming of a new democratic era in Iraq with the bloody warfare that has pinned 140,000 American troops in that misery-laden country with no end in sight.

In 90 minutes before the biggest audience of the campaign, Bush not only failed to do that — he barely tried. And that omission leaves him at risk to future events as the insurgency in Iraq gathers momentum.

Instead of dealing with his greatest vulnerability, Bush did what was predictable. He repeated the favorite examples his campaign has gleaned from the abundant contradictions on Iraq policy Kerry has uttered since he first voted to authorize the use of force against Saddam Hussein back in 2002. It is a catalogue that has become familiar through millions of dollars of Republican ads, and by the time Bush had used the same phrase seven times — citing Kerry’s dismissal of Iraq as the “wrong war in the wrong place at the wrong time” — there was a rote quality to the recital that reduced its sting.

On a day when the headlines carried news of more than 40 deaths — most of them children — from insurgent attacks Bush pronounced himself “realistic but optimistic” about the course of events in Iraq. Kerry briefly challenged that picture, arguing that “it’s getting worse by the day.” But Bush never responded directly, and estimable moderator Jim Lehrer inexplicably failed to ask the president to reconcile the glaring contradiction between the White House version of events in Iraq and the reality of the growing resistance.

I have argued for a long time that Bush’s real opponent in this campaign is not John Kerry but the Iraqi insurgency, and unfortunately that is turning out to be the case. Bush did nothing during the debate to defuse the threat.

But Kerry did himself some good by refusing to be defensive about his checkered history on Iraq or attempting yet one more convoluted explanation of his incoherent past positions. Instead, he focused on future steps. His preferred solution for Iraq, starting with “a summit” of European and Middle East nations to drum up more international peacekeeping forces, may be a long shot, but when Bush failed to challenge Kerry’s contention that the president’s plan is simply “more of the same,” the gamble did not seem totally implausible.

I thought I saw Bush wince a bit when Kerry recalled that the president’s father had not tried to topple Saddam Hussein at the end of the Persian Gulf War of 1991 because he said “there was no viable exit strategy and . . . our troops would be occupiers in a bitterly hostile land.”

“That’s exactly where we find ourselves today,” Kerry said. And though he vowed he would not pull out of Iraq without a victory, the implication of his words is clear: If Kerry wins, the future of Iraq will be left to Iraqis.

The debate confirmed that Kerry is simply incapable of appealing to people in personal terms. The kind of emotion Bush displayed when talking about Missy Johnson, the war widow he had comforted in Charlotte, just does not come from Kerry.

But he succeeded last night in separating the war in Iraq from the war on terrorism — something Bush does not want to let happen — and for the moment at least, his demeanor made it believable for him to say, “I’ve never wilted in my life. And I’ve never wavered in my life.”

For a man who was on the ropes a couple weeks ago, it was at least enough to keep the fight going.


erry won the debate, according to instant polls

Updated 01:27pm (Mla time) Oct 01, 2004
Agence France-Presse

Get INQ7 breaking news on your Smart mobile phone in the Philippines. Send INQ7 BREAKING to 386.

WASHINGTON, District of Columbia, United States of America — Democratic challenger John Kerry won the first televised presidential debate against Republican President George W. Bush late Thursday, according to instant polls released after.

A Gallup poll for CNN gave Kerry a 46 percent to 37 percent win over the president.

It added that 46 percent of those asked now have a better opinion of Kerry against 21 percent for Bush.

The CBS network, which asked 200 voters, said 44 percent gave victory to Kerry against 26 percent who thought the president had the upper hand. Thirty percent said neither candidate won.

An ABC poll of 531 people gave 45 percent for Kerry, 36 percent for Bush and 17 percent for a draw.

Democratic National Committee (DNC) �
Estados Unidos
Pol�tica > Elecciones
Noticia n�: 34775
Agencia emisora:
vie 01 Oct 2004

The National Verdict is In: John Kerry Wins First Debate

Washington, DC � The reviews are in and according to the talking heads and today’s news it is clear that at last night’s debate America saw John Kerry as the next President of the United States. Kerry’s strength, conviction, and steady command of the facts left no doubt that he can lead the fight on terrorism and finish the job in Iraq. Kerry beat expectations, he looked presidential, and he proved his foreign policy credentials.

But don’t take out our word for it:


Joe Scarborough: “John Kerry won the debate. Karl Rove: John Kerry won the debate.” [MSNBC, 10/1/04]

Peggy Noonan: “Mr. Kerry did himself some good in that he seemed focused, to my mind, for once.” [Fox News Channel, 9/20/04]

Sen. John McCain: “I think that Kerry did a good job.” [MSNBC, 9/30/04]

Fred Barnes: “Kerry did very well and we will have a presidential race from here on out” [Fox News Channel, 9/30/04]

Howard Fineman: “Kerry won the event.” [MSNBC, 10/1/04]

Mark Whitaker, Newsweek: “I think Kerry won on style in this debate.” [CNN, 9/30/04]

Joe Scarborough: “It was John Kerry’s best performance ever�As far as the debate goes, I don’t see how anybody could look at this debate and not score this a very clear win on points for John Kerry.” [MSNBC, 9/30/04]

Ron Reagan: “Kerry was the clear winner.” [MSNBC, 9/30/04]

Bill Kristol: “I think Kerry did pretty well.” [Fox News Channel, 9/30/04]

Andrea Mitchell: “Kerry began to narrow the gap.” [MSNBC, 9/30/04]

Chris Matthews: “I thought it was smart for Kerry to keep going back to saying that 90% of the casualties were American. For the President to deny that is going against American perceptions.” [MSNBC, 9/30/04]

Craig Crawford: “Kerry was good about not being put on the defensive. There were many opportunities he may have wanted to respond to the mixed messages that Bush kept talking about, he would just kind of laugh and let it go and make his points. He won the cutaway shots.” [MSNBC, 10/1/04]

George Stephanopoulos: “Kerry has momentum coming out of here.” [ABC, 9/30/04]

Boston Globe Headline: “Kerry stays focused, projects strength” [10/1/04]

Los Angles Times Headline: “TV Analysts Give Kerry an Early Lead in Quest for Spin” [10/1/04]


0 Responses to “No Bullshit Polls – 1 Oct 2004”

  1. Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

October 2004
« Sep   Nov »

Top Posts

Flickr Photos

Blog Stats

  • 6,229 hits

%d bloggers like this: